image
image
  • Best NY Style Pizza in the Utica Area!
  • Menu
    • Main Menu
    • Catering Menu
  • About
    • Who We Are
    • Gallery
  • Gift Cards
  • Tap Room
  • Rewards
  • Order Now
  • Apparel
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Social
    • Social Wall
    • Reviews
    • Blog
  • Contact
  • JOIN THE BOYS
  • More
    • Best NY Style Pizza in the Utica Area!
    • Menu
      • Main Menu
      • Catering Menu
    • About
      • Who We Are
      • Gallery
    • Gift Cards
    • Tap Room
    • Rewards
    • Order Now
    • Apparel
    • Specials
    • Events
    • Social
      • Social Wall
      • Reviews
      • Blog
    • Contact
    • JOIN THE BOYS
NY MILLS ORDER NOW

Daily Specials

  • Monday - Boneless Wings

    1/2 Price

  • Tuesday - All Slices $1.00

    All Day!!

    $1.00

  • Wed. Night - Strings & Wings

    Live Music 6-9pm 

    60c Wings 4-9pm

  • Thursday - Chicken Riggies $8.50

    All Day!!

    $8.50

  • Friday - Lg Fish Subs $6.00

    All Day!!

    $6.00

True New York Pizza

Tuesday $1 Slices All Day!
  • Personal 10”

    6 Cut Cheese or Garlic

    $7.99

  • Medium 14”

    8 Cut Cheese or Garlic

    $10.99

  • Large 16”

    8 Cut Cheese or Garlic

    $13.99

  • X-Large 18”

    10 Cut Cheese or Garlic

    $15.99

Wings & Boneless Wings

1/2 Price Boneless Wings All Day Monday! Try Our New BOOM BOOM Sauce! 60¢ Wings Wednesday 4pm-9pm
  • Celery & Blue Cheese $2.00

    $2.00

Traditional Buffalo Style
  • Mild $9.99+
  • Medium $9.99+
  • Hot $9.99+
  • Inferno $9.99+
11 Flavor Kings
  • Gold Dust $9.99+
  • BBQ $9.99+
  • Everything $9.99+
  • Buffalo Garlic $8.99+
  • Buffalo BBQ $8.99+
  • Sweet & Sour $8.99+
  • Honey Mustard $9.99+
  • Blue Hot $9.99+
  • Garlic Parmesan $8.99+
  • Sweet & Tangy $9.99+
  • Honey BBQ $9.99+

Melts

$9.99 - All melts include chips and a pickle With Curly Fries, French Fries
  • Turkey Bacon Melt $9.99

    American Cheese & Tomato

    $9.99

  • Chicken Parmesan Melt $9.99

    Mozzarella Cheese & Marinara Sauce

    $9.99

  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Melt $9.99

    Mozzarella Cheese, Ranch & Tomato

    $9.99

  • Steak & Cheese Melt $9.99

    Peppers, Mushrooms, Onion & Mozzarella Cheese

    $9.99

  • The Italian Melt $9.99

    Cappi Ham, Pepperoni, Salami, Provolone, & Tomato

    $9.99

  • Buffalo Chicken Melt $9.99

    Mozzarella Cheese & Tomato

    $9.99

  • Ruben Melt $9.99

    Corned Beef, Russian, Sauerkraut & Swiss Cheese

    $9.99

  • French Dip Melt $9.99

    Roast Beef, Mozzarella Cheese, & Savory Au Jus

    $9.99

  • Tuna Melt $9.99

    American Cheese & Tomato

    $9.99

Specialty Pies

SM $9.99 M $13.99 L $16.99 XL $19.99
  • Buffalo Chicken $10.99+

    Buffalo Sauce, Grilled Chicken, & Mozzarella Cheese

  • Popeye’s Pie $10.99+

    Fresh Spinach, Tomatoes, Garlic, Ricotta & Mozzarella Cheese

  • Gold Dust Chicken $10.99+

    Gold Dust Chicken & Mozzarella Cheese

  • Carnivore $10.99+

    Pepperoni, Sausage, Meatballs, Ham, Bacon & Mozzarella Cheese

  • Chicken Bacon Ranch $10.99+

    Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Ranch & Mozzarella Cheese

  • E.B.A. $10.99+

    Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushroom, Peppers, Onions & Mozzarella Cheese

  • Tree Hugger $10.99+

    Tomato, Onion, Broccoli, Garlic, Ricotta, & Mozzarella Cheese

  • Mac Daddy $10.99+

    Secret Sauce, Ground Beef, Tomato, Onion, Mozzarella & American Cheese, topped with Lettuce

  • Mac and Cheese $10.99+

    Cheddar Cheese Sauce, Pasta & Mozzarella Cheese. Topped with breadcrumbs!

  • Philly Steak $10.99+

    Mushrooms, Peppers, Onions, White American & Mozzarella Cheese

  • The Grandma $21.99

    Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Basil, Fresh Garlic & Plumb Tomato One Size

    $21.99

  • Sicilian Upside Down $17.99

    (Toppings Extra) One Size

    $17.99

  • Hawaiian $10.99+

    Ham, Pineapple, Bacon & Mozzarella Cheese

Baskets

All Baskets Include Curly Fries, French Fries Or Tots
  • Boneless Buffalo Wings (10) $9.99

    Dipped in your choice of Wing Sauce, Served w/Blue Cheese

    $9.99

  • Chicken Tender Basket $9.99

    Choice of Honey Mustard, BBQ, or Sweet n Sour

    $9.99

  • Fried Clam Basket $8.99

    Choice of Tarter or Cocktail Sauce

    $8.99

  • Shrimp Basket (10) $9.99

    Try them Garlic Parm or Buffalo style!

    $9.99

  • Fish & Chips Basket $8.99

    Choice of Tarter or Cocktail Sauce

    $8.99

  • Fish Fry Dinner $10.99

    Served With Grandma’s Coleslaw, Fries, Tarter Sauce, and Garlic Toast

    $10.99

  • Fish & Shrimp Dinner $14.99

    Served With Coconut Shrimp, Grandma’s Coleslaw, Fries, Garlic Toast, Tarter & Mango Salsa

    $14.99

Subs & Wraps

All Cold subs and wraps include: Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, American Cheese, Oil, Vinegar & Mayonnaise
  • Ham

    Small 8’’ $6.99    Large 12’’ $7.99   Wrap $6.99

  • Turkey

    Small 8’’ $6.99    Large 12’’ $7.99   Wrap $6.99

  • Roast Beef $9.99

    Small 8’’ $6.99    Large 12’’ $7.99   Wrap $6.99

  • Tuna

    Small 8’’ $6.99    Large 12’’ $7.99   Wrap $6.99

  • Chicken Club

    Toasted with bacon.

    Small 8’’ $7.99    Large 12’’ $8.99   Wrap $7.75

  • Turkey Club

    Toasted with bacon.

    Small 8’’ $7.99    Large 12’’ $8.99   Wrap $7.75

  • Mixed

    Pepperoni, Ham, and Salami.

    Small 8’’ $6.99    Large 12’’ $7.99   Wrap $6.99

  • Italian Mix

    Cappi Ham, Salami, and Pepperoni.

    Small 8’’ $6.99    Large 12’’ $7.99   Wrap $6.99

  • B.L.T. Sub

    Small 8’’ $6.99    Large 12’’ $7.99   Wrap $6.75

  • Cheeseburger Sub

    Small 8’’ $7.99    Large 12’’ $8.99   Wrap $7.75

Killer Burgers

All Burgers Include a Pickle and Choice of Curly Fries, French Fries or Tots May substitute a side salad for 1.99
  • Deluxe Hamburger $8.79

    $8.79

  • Deluxe Cheeseburger

    $8.99

  • Deluxe Bacon Cheeseburger

    Above burgers Dressed with Lettuce,Tomato, Mayo, Ketchup & Mustard

    $9.99

  • Road House BBQ Bacon Burger

    Topped with onion petals and Provolone Cheese

    $9.99

  • Bacon, Ranch Cheeseburger $9.99

    $9.99

  • Bacon, Mushroom & Swiss Burger

    Above burgers Dressed with Lettuce & Tomato. Double Any Burger Add 2.25

    $9.99

Pizza & Wing Deals

Served All Day Everyday!!! (May Substitute Boneless Wings) (Toppings Extra)
  • Personal 10” Cheese Pizza & 1/2 Dozen

    $12.99

  • Medium 14” Cheese Pizza & 20 Wings

    $26.99

  • Medium 14” Cheese Pizza & 10 Wings

    $18.99

  • 2 Medium 14”Cheese Pizzas & 30 Wings

    $42.99

  • Large 16” Cheese Pizza & 20 Wings

    $28.99

  • Large 16” Cheese Pizza & 30 Wings

    $37.99

  • 2 Large 16” Cheese Pizzas & 50 Wings

    $59.99

  • X-Large 18” Cheese Pizza & 50 Wings $49.99

    $47.99

Pasta Dinners

All Pasta Dinners Served with Garlic Toast and a Side Salad. Thursday $8.50 Chicken Riggies All Day!
  • Ziti with Meatballs

    $10.99

  • Baked Ziti

    $10.99

  • Chicken Broccoli Alfredo

    $12.99

  • Chicken Riggies

    $12.99

  • Chicken Parmesan Over Ziti

    $12.99

  • Buffalo Chicken Pasta

    $12.99

Calzones

Try Our Buffalo Chicken Zone!
  • Calzones

    Try Our Buffalo Chicken Zone! Fresh pizza dough stuffed with Mozzarella & Ricotta Cheese Calzones include Choice of 2 Pizza Toppings, Additional Pizza Toppings .75

    8.99

Family Deal

  • Family Deal 1 $28.99

    XL Cheese Pizza (Toppings Extra), 20 Wings & 2-Liter

    $28.99

  • Family Deal 2 $28.99

    Large Cheese Pizza (Toppings Extra), Large Order Baked Ziti, Texas Toast, Large Tossed Salad & 2 Liter

    $28.99

Hot Subs

Add Hot Cherry Peppers to Your Philly, You Will Love It! Friday $6 Fish Subs ALL Day!!
  • Meatball

    Sm. 8" $7.99    Lg. 12" $8.99

  • Gold Dust Chicken Sandwich

    Sm. 8" $7.99    Lg. 12" $8.99

  • Chicken Parmesan

    Sm. 8" $7.99    Lg. 12" $8.99

  • Chicken Bacon Ranch

    Sm. 8" $7.99    Lg. 12" $8.99

  • Buffalo Chicken

    Sm. 8" $7.99    Lg. 12" $8.99

  • Ruben

    Sm. 8" $7.99    Lg. 12" $8.99

  • Steak & Cheddar

    Sm. 8" $7.99    Lg. 12" $9.99

  • Philly Cheese Steak

    Sm. 8" $7.99    Lg. 12" $8.99

  • Fish Sub

    American Cheese, Lettuce & Tartar Sauce

    $8.99

Catering Menu

Party Trays
  • Garden Tossed Salad

    Half Tray  $20        Full Tray  $35

  • Antipasto Salad

    Half Tray  $25        Full Tray  $45

  • Chicken Caesar Salad

    Half Tray  $25       Full Tray  $45

  • Ziti Marinara

    Half Tray $25    Full Tray $45

  • Baked Ziti w/Mozzarella

    Half Tray  $30        Full Tray  $50

  • Meatballs in Sauce

    Half Tray  $35        Full Tray  $65

  • Sausage & Peppers

    Half Tray  $40        Full Tray  $75

  • Chicken Riggies

    Half Tray  $45        Full Tray  $85

  • Utica Greens

    Half Tray  $45        Full Tray  $85

Party Rolls
  • Party Rolls $15 $15.00

    • Antipasto (onions, cappi ham, salami & pepperoni)

     • Sausage • Pepperoni 

    • Stromboli (ham, pepperoni & salami) 

    • Buffalo Chicken • Spinach

Party Favs
  • Assorted Sub Platter (30 pc) $45

    (5 Turkey, 5 Ham, 5 Roast Beef, 5 Mixed, 5 Italian Mix, 5 Tuna) 

  • Crispy Chicken Tenders w/Dip (25 pc)

    $30

  • Utica Tomato Pie

    $ 12

  • Garlic Knots (30 pc)

    $ 14

  • Garlic Bread (30 pc)

    $ 14

  • Dinner Rolls with Butter (30 pc)

    $ 12

Pizza & Wings
  • 5 Large Cheese Pizzas (toppings extra)

    $ 55

  • Each additional Large Cheese Pizza (toppings extra)

    $ 11

  • 2 Large Pizzas & 50 Chicken Wings

     $ 55

  • 100 Chicken Wings

     $75

    Mild - Medium - Hot - Garlic Parm - BBQ

  • Celery & Blue Cheese Platter

    $10

  • Dozen Cannolis

    $ 20

Italian Fare
  • Italian Fare $8.99 per person

    Baked Ziti w/Mozzarella
    Meatballs in Sauce
    Garden Tossed Salad
    Italian Sausage & Peppers
    Tomato Pie
    Dinner Rolls

    Includes utensils, set up & free delivery within 10 driving miles Chafers & Sterno Candles provided for an additional $1 per person

    *no substitutions *minimum 15 person order 

Premium Italian Fare
  • Premium Italian Fare $11.99 per person

    Chicken Riggies
    Utica Greens
    Antipasto Salad
    Italian Sausage & Peppers
    Tomato Pie
    Dinner Rolls

    Includes utensils, set up & free delivery within 10 driving miles Chafers & Sterno Candles provided for an additional $1 per person

    *no substitutions *minimum 15 person order 

5 LARGE Cheese Pizzas
  • 5 LARGE Cheese Pizzas

    $ 55

2 LARGE Cheese Pizzas & 50 Chicken Wings
  • 2 LARGE Cheese Pizzas & 50 Chicken Wings

    $ 55

Download Menu
  • Pizza Boys © 2021
  • A Mopro Website
Back to Top